
Imagine a finance clerk who has spent five years capturing supplier invoices. When the payments manager goes on leave, the clerk is asked to step in and is given authority to release payments. The employee knows the business and has earned the team’s trust. The CFO must ask whether the checks and controls in place when the employee joined are sufficient for the authority they are about to exercise.
Start with what the employee will be able to do
A new title can change very little. A new banking mandate or administrator login can change a great deal, even when the title stays the same. Start with the difference between the employee’s existing duties and the responsibilities they will take on. Then ask what the employer has already verified, whether that evidence is still relevant and whether a further check would address a specific gap.
In the payments example, the CFO might first look at who can change a supplier’s bank details and who can release the payment. Independent confirmation of bank-detail changes and dual approval address that risk directly. If the acting role also requires a professional credential the employer has never verified, confirming it with the issuing body may be appropriate. Each safeguard addresses a different risk.
Reassessment triggers for HR and audit committees
- Financial authority changes. Review new authority to release payments, approve refunds, sign contracts or change supplier banking details. Confirm approval limits and who independently checks transactions.
- Sensitive access expands. Review new access to payroll, customer records, investigation files or privileged system accounts. Confirm which permissions are required and when temporary access will expire.
- An employee moves into procurement, investigations or another role with conflict-of-interest exposure. Consider whether a targeted declaration of relevant interests would address the risk.
- A role introduces a qualification, registration or licence requirement. Verify the credential you need and check its current status where it can lapse.
- An acting appointment, secondment or transfer changes any of the above. Review the actual authority before granting access, even when the appointment is brief.
For each trigger, record what changed, what evidence already exists, and who approved any further check. A documented decision to rely on existing evidence gives auditors something concrete to review.
Keep continuous vetting proportionate
A role-based programme can use changes in duties and, where justified, scheduled checks for requirements that can expire. For example, a professional registration may need periodic confirmation when it is required for the work. Set the purpose, scope and frequency in advance and explain them to employees. Routine scrutiny of private messages or personal social media goes beyond a targeted role reassessment and raises separate privacy questions.
Under the Protection of Personal Information Act (POPIA), define the purpose, identify a lawful basis and limit collection to information relevant to the role. If you intend to reuse information collected at hiring, assess whether that use is compatible with the original purpose under section 15. Meet applicable notification requirements, restrict access to those who need the information and protect and retain it in line with POPIA. Information
Give employees a fair opportunity to respond
Explain the proposed checks early and apply the same role criteria consistently. If a result raises a concern, confirm its accuracy and relevance, then give the employee a meaningful opportunity to explain or correct it before making an adverse decision. Consider whether a narrower control, such as a lower approval limit or supervised access, would address the risk.
The Labour Relations Act includes unfair conduct relating to promotion or demotion within its unfair labour practice provisions. If dismissal is contemplated, it requires a fair reason and a fair procedure. The Employment Equity Act also prohibits unfair discrimination in employment policies and practices. A screening result is one input into the decision. HR still needs to assess the facts and follow the applicable employment process.
At your next audit or governance committee meeting, ask for one recent internal promotion and one temporary delegation. Can the business show what changed, who approved the new authority and why any further screening was justified?
iFacts can help you turn those decisions into a role-based vetting policy that HR, finance and audit can apply consistently.
011 453 1587
